CELLULOID DREAMS - The Movie Show

Review - The History Boys (2006)
Home
The Crew
Featured Audio
Past Guests
Reviews
The Wider Angle
FIlm Festival Coverage
Banners & Graphics
Awards
Fact Sheet
Contact Us

 

The History Boys (*** out of ****)

Twentieth Century Fox

Reviewed by Tim Sika

 

For all of its lofty thematic aspirations (they are many) and the filmmakers abounding attempts for you to consider them as such (you should) the Big Question that nags as the end credits of The History Boys roll, is not so much what constitutes history; how important learning for its own sake is; or what is more worthwhile—knowledge or truth—but rather, why isn’t anybody writing great songs and lyrics like “Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered” anymore?

 

Alex Bennett’s version of his Tony Award winning play successfully scales back its theatricality and does, to its credit, create a movie with a movie sensibility here, but in so doing, ironically—and oddly—bleaches the original source material. The approach is skillful, cognizant of the differences between the two mediums, but one cannot help but wonder how the sum total effect of this story might have been better served had the playwright  been more faithful—literally—to his original text.

 

Director Nicholas Hytner and cast’s affection for this solidly resonant material seems genuine and committed (most of the cast and crew from the play repeat their roles for the movie version) and all laudably deliver on the author’s concept.  Still, this clearly-thought- out movie version of a near-great contemporary play comes across as pinched; its thematic density and contemplative-worthy prose seemingly too buried beneath its cinematic veneer, as well as the author’s apparent desire to make it more movie-friendly. (This could, however, work to the film’s advantage on repeated viewings).

 

What is ultimately irksome about The History Boys is that it feels downright egregious to dismiss it out-of-hand, and yet it feels right. On the other hand, there’s something to be savored about a film so rigorously erudite and earnestly intentioned as this one is, with enough evocative period academic ethos, sexual politics and considered thought to fill three, four or five movies. (When you think about it, when was the last time you remember sitting through a film laden with substantial bits of Dickens, Hardy and Keats which actually added to its plot, or experienced the sublimity of a near-perfect Rodgers and Hart tune and lyric, as wondrously woven into the fabric of its narrative as it is here?).

 

2006 Tim Sika/Celluloid Dreams

 

BACK TO REVIEWS

 HOME    THE CREW    FEATURED AUDIO    PAST GUESTS    REVIEWS    THE WIDER ANGLE   BANNERS    FILM FESTIVAL COVERAGE    AWARDS    FACT SHEET    CONTACT    KSJS 
___________________________________________
All content including Celluloid Dreams name, logo and tagline© 1996-2018 CELLULOID DREAMS/ Tim Sika, Larry Jakubecz 

Web site design by JAK